无“处分行为”,何来“善意取得”？——从“无处分权”角度谈留置权的善意取得

由于对善意取得适用范围的不同理解,传统善意取得制度的构成要件大多已遭质疑,因此本文从“出让人无处分权为处分行为”这一唯一尚未定论的要件入手,用处分行为和处分权理论分析不动产物权和留置权的善意取得问题,认为,不动产物权由于登记的公示效力,对善意第三人构成有权处分,而留置权本身则完全建立在负担行为的框架之上,因而均不宜适用善意取得。

No Disposition, How to Compose the Bona Fide Acquisition?--On the Bona Fide Acquisition of the Right of Lien

Most of the traditional essential components of the system of the Bona Fide Acquisition have been encountered suspicions because of the different views of the scope of its application.So the author chooses "the unauthorized disposition" that is the only well accepted component as the base of this paper,using the theory of disposal,analyzes the rationality of the Bona Fide Acquisition of the rights of Lien and draws the conclusion that the right of lien is a strike root on the frame of encumbrance which is on the contrary of disposal.As a result,it should not apply to this system.