Betterness,injustice and failed athletic contests |
| |
Authors: | Arvi Pakaslahti |
| |
Institution: | Philosophy Unit, University of Turku, Turku, Finland |
| |
Abstract: | In this paper, I provide an account of failed athletic contests which consists of two ideals, the Athletic Superiority Ideal and the Just Results Ideal. Related to this, I argue that a sports contest can fail in terms of the Athletic Superiority Ideal without failing in terms of the Just Results Ideal and vice versa. In the process of doing the former, I argue that besides adjudicating errors, cheating, gamesmanship and (bad) luck, there are two other types of reasons because of which a sports contest can fail in terms of the Athletic Superiority Ideal. Finally, I argue that my account of failed athletic contests is more plausible than Mika Hämäläinen’s three-standard model of athletic superiority. |
| |
Keywords: | Betterness desert injustice ranking systems rule violations |
|
|