暂缓判决制度之质疑

从适用对象的角度对审判实践中总结出的暂缓判决适用对象进行分析和推导,得出暂缓判决没有合适的适用范围存在.从法理的角度对暂缓判决的适用对象进行分析,发现暂缓判决适用对象与缓刑的适用对象一致,两者产生竞合.缓刑是刑法中明文规定的制度,在审判实践中通常会被优先适用,由此也印证了审判实践中暂缓判决的尴尬处境.

Question the Suspend Judgment System

From the angle of applicable object, analyzing and deducing the applicable object of suspend judgments summed up in judicial practice, no corresponding applicable object range is to be found. So does from the angle of legal principle, no difference in applicable object between suspend judgment and probation. Being an official system proclaimed in Criminal Law, the probation system is given the priority in practice, thus the awkward position of suspend judgment is confirmed.