张竹坡小说评点之疑窦和原因——试论吴月娘孟玉楼公案

张竹坡评点《金瓶梅》,在古代小说评点中是重要一家,历来受人称道,但是分析张竹坡对吴月娘、孟玉楼两位重要人物的强烈褒贬,发现张竹坡的人物评点与故事情节和形象体系若即若离,褒贬评判多而逻辑论证少。这种状况与传统评点的丹黄圈点和判语抑扬方式有关,其思辨模式和表述方式应当客观分析并且有所扬弃。

The Doubts and the Reasons for Zhang Zhupo's Novel Critique: On the Case of Wu Yueniang and Meng Yulou

Zhang Zhupo＇s comment on Chin Ping Mei has already won a place of praise in the criticism of ancient novels. But when we analyse Zhang Zhupo＇s judgment of Wu Yueniang and Meng Yulou, we will find that Zhang Zhupo＇s character comment maintains a lukewarm relationship with storyline and image system, in which judgement outweighs logical argument. This situation is concerned with the traditional annotation and the mode of judgment, whose speculative mode and presentation methods should be objectively analyzed and properly selected.