Combinatorial proofs and algebraic proofs — II

In Part I of this article we considered some binomial identities and also some identities involving the Fibonacci numbers, and proved them using methods which we described as ‘largely’ combinatorial. Now we shift our focus to number theory and to prime numbers in particular, and showcase some proofs having a strong combinatorial element. Throughout this article, p denotes an odd prime.     

Secondary teachers’ knowledge of elementary number theory proofs: the case of general-cover proofs

In light of recent reform recommendations, teachers are expected to turn proofs and proving into an ongoing component of their classroom practice. Two questions emerging from this requirement are: Is the mathematical knowledge of high school teachers sufficient to prove various kinds of statements? Does teachers’ knowledge allow them to determine the validity of an argument made by their students? The results of this study, in which 50 secondary school teachers participated, point to a positive answer to the first question in the framework of elementary number theory (ENT). However, the picture is more complex with respect to the second one. Results indicated that some teachers may over-value the generality of symbolic mode of representation and under-value the generality of verbal ones. Possibly, the verbal representation of an argument is less transparent and more difficult to understand.     

When is less more? Investigating gap-filling in proofs without words activities

Educational Studies in Mathematics - Visuospatial representations of numbers and their relationships are widely used in mathematics education. These include drawn images, models constructed with...     

First‐year secondary school mathematics students’ conceptions of mathematical proofs and proving

The aim of this study is to investigate students’ conceptions about proof in mathematics and mathematics teaching. A five‐point Likert‐type questionnaire was administered in order to gather data. The sample of the study included 33 first‐year secondary school mathematics students (at the same time student teachers). The data collected were analysed and interpreted using the methods of qualitative and quantitative analysis. The results have revealed that the students think that mathematical proof has an important place in mathematics and mathematics education. The students’ studying methods for exams based on imitative reasoning which can be described as a type of reasoning built on copying proof, for example, by looking at a textbook or course notes proof or through remembering a proof algorithm. Moreover, they addressed to the differences between mathematics taught in high school and university as the main cause of their difficulties in proof and proving.     

Minding mathematicians’ discourses in investigations of their feedback on students’ proofs: a case study

Educational Studies in Mathematics - This article presents a research apparatus for investigating and making sense of stories that emerge from feedback that mathematicians provide on...