世纪回望是非成败从头说--辛亥革命的地位述论

辛亥革命的地位研究经历了曲折前进的过程,从革命史观到“立足于批”,然后经过“拨乱反正”发展成如今百花齐放的局面。谈文重点考察“拨乱反正”后国内外各个学术流派和众多学者的不同论点与视角,在比较中考察其学术上的价值与得失,并根据学术界的主流评价给予辛亥革命一个并非定论的定位。

Commenting on the rights and wrongs of the Xinhai Revolution from the beginning while we recollecting it after a century --The remark on the status of Xinhai Revolution

Basing on the historical concept of revolution to "being established in animadverting",eventually succeeded in forming a fine complexion of "all flowers are in bloom" after bringing order out of chaos,the disquisition on the status of the Xinhai Revolution has come through devious course.This article pays more attentions to the different arguments and visual angles of various academic genres and scholars at home and aboard after the course of bringing order out of chaos,and tries to inspect their value and their gain and loss in systematic,finally gives the Xinhai Revolution a temporary orientation but not a verdict according to the main comment in current academe.