理论与实践：档案存毁之间并无博弈——与周林兴、吕维商榷

《价值与认知：档案存毁之间的博弈》再次提出了弱化档案鉴定的观点。文章针对部分作者的文章做了批评,引用了诸多案例,来证明自己的观点。然而其论述有自相矛盾之处,其批评也有断章取义之嫌,案例引用亦有不当之处。文章反映了作者对现实中的档案工作严重缺乏了解。

Theory and Practice: No Game between Archives Preservation and Destruction

Value and Cognition: the Game Between Archives Preservation And Destruction put forward the viewpoint of weakening archives appraisal. This paper criticizes the articles of some authors and quotes a lot of cases to prove its point. But its discussions are self-contradictory and its criticisms are taken out of context. Many cases are wrong. This paper reflectes that the authors are lack of understanding of the real archives work.