Some Achilles' Heels of Thinking Skills: a Response to Higgins and Baumfield |
| |
Authors: | S Johnson & P Gardner |
| |
Institution: | Academic Studies, North Warwickshire College, Hinckley Road, Nuneaton, CV11 6BH,;45 Highfield Avenue, Morton, Carlisle, CA2 6NH, UK |
| |
Abstract: | Steven Higgins and Vivienne Baumfield have recently attempted to defend the much discussed idea of general thinking skills against attacks from three quarters: what they regard as a priori objections, which they liken to Zeno's paradox that Achilles will not catch the tortoise; domains theories of knowledge, which oppose the idea of thinking skills being general and transcending domains; and the claim that experts use subject specific knowledge, and don't use general thinking skills. We examine these defences and find them flawed and worrying. We conclude that this is a domain in serious need of a priori approaches. |
| |
Keywords: | |
|
|