“意见”是否属于刑法司法解释表现形式问题探析

刑法学界对＂意见＂是否属于司法解释表现形式问题的认识并不统一,主要有肯定与否定两种认识观点。否定性观点认为,＂意见＂不是司法解释,而是司法解释性文件,不能在裁判文书中直接援引。而肯定性观点则与此相反,认为从规定的内容看,系对审理受贿案件如何应用法律的解释,应属于司法解释的内容。应当说,肯定＂意见＂属于司法解释的观点更有其合理性与说服力。

"Views" is a Criminal Justice to Explain the Problem of the Form

The field of criminal law does not have the unified agreement on the idea ＂opinion＂,which have two opposite views：positive and negative.The negative view thinks that ＂opinion＂ is not a judicial interpretations but judicial interpretation file,which cannot be invoked directly in the documents.While the positive view,on the contrary,thinks that it is the content of judicial interpretation from the provisions of the content,which is actually the explanation of how to use law to deal with bribery cases.It must say that latterview is more of legitimacy and persuasiveness.