Real-time factors in the rabbit’s nictitating membrane response to pulsed and serial conditioned stimuli

Conditioning theories and recent real-time models commonly postulate that a reinforcer is signaled by a series of stimuli. In both Pavlovian and operant procedures, serial stimuli have been shown to control the likelihood and timing of responses over intervals of seconds and minutes. The present experiments were conducted to determine whether serial stimuli exercise similar effects over stimulus-reinforcer intervals in the order of hundreds of milliseconds. Such intervals typify those used in conditioning of the rabbit nictitating membrane response. A sequence of four tone pulses (50–100 msec) was used as the CS to assess the effectiveness of serial stimuli. After training with this CS, tests were conducted in which one or more of the pulses were removed. These perturbations of the sequence of stimuli over a 400-msec interval produced large deficits in CR likelihood and smaller alterations in CR timing. The results are discussed with respect to their implications for current real-time models of conditioning, and particularly with respect to their assumptions about the source of internal stimuli, rules for learning, and rules for generating CRs.